Confronted by her one-night stand over the existence of magic, excommunicated witch Alyssa Singer finally spills her deepest secrets. And, with all the cards on the table, she's worried the police might have the wrong man in custody as the serial killer targeting Baltimore's witching community. To solve the case, Alyssa's going to have to finally face her estranged father, the powerful witch who kicked her out of the family ten years prior.